• 01 OCT 13
    • 0

    Conceding Guilt at Trial

    Conceding Guilt at Trial

     

    Sometimes criminal defense attorneys have to defend a case where the evidence against the accused is insurmountable on some or all of the charges. In cases where some of charges are a “slam dunk” for the prosecutors, a defense attorney may make the strategic decision to concede guilt on these charges and defend against the remaining charges only.

    In a recent decision by the Nevada Supreme Court, the Court decided a case such as this and held what duties, if any, a criminal defense attorney has when making a strategic decision to concede guilt.

     

    In Hernandez v. State, the Nevada Supreme Court held that in order to concede guilt at the time of trial, a canvass of the defendant must be held by the court, outside the presence of the prosecuting attorney and jury to make sure the defendant understands all the ramifications of this plea. But, in Armenia-Carpio v. State, the Nevada Supreme Court overruled this prior decision, holding instead that a decision to concede guilt is a strategic decision – nothing more, nothing less. The Courts prior rationale in Hernandez basically equated a decision to concede guilt as the functional equivalent of a guilty plea.

     

    However, in Armenta-Carpio, decided July 25,2013, the Court ultimately held that a canvass was not necessary when deciding to concede guilt. In making this decision, the Nevada Supreme Court aligned its holding with that of the United States Supreme Court.

     

    Leave a reply →

If you need a lawyer who has the strength, compassion and experience to get results for you and your children, contact Bellon & Maningo. Call 702-452-6299 or e-mail the firm to arrange a consultation.

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Your Phone (required)


Practice Area of Interest
Civil LawCriminal Law
Family Law

Brief description of your legal issue


captcha



I understand attorney-client
relationship is not established
by use of this webform.

Bellon & Maningo, Ltd.
732 South 6th Street, Suite 102
Las Vegas, NV 89101

Phone: 702-452-6299
Fax: 702-452-6298

Map and Directions